Modern financial trading
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh,
I am learning modern financial tradings like ( Forex, Leverage, Futures, CFDs, Indices, and Prop Firms). And I want to make sure that whatever I eventually do is permissible according to shariah.
For any business deal to be allowed in Islamic law, it must meet a few basic conditions. The modern trading methods you asked about do not follow these conditions, which makes all of them non permissible.
“What are the certain conditions?”
1, When trading different currencies with one another, at least one of the currencies must be taken into possession immediately; otherwise, the transaction is not permissible.
In many retail (forex trading) transactions, the currencies are represented through account entries rather than through the physical delivery of banknotes. The trader typically acquires a contractual or account-based position in the currency. It is not possible for us to obtain the currencies physically under any circumstances.
Therefore, merely displaying a “Buy” option on a trading app and recording a currency position in the account does not, by itself, constitute actual possession (qabḍ) of that currency.Therefore, this transaction is not permissible.
2, Under Islamic law, a transaction involving substantial uncertainty (gharar) or deception is not permissible.
Certain forms of retail Forex trading may resemble gambling (qimār) in their structure, particularly where the transaction involves taking speculative positions on exchange-rate movements without actual possession of the underlying currencies, with the gain of one party corresponding to the loss of another.
(CFDs trading) uses the same method.The only difference is that, instead of currencies, other commodities are traded here.
3, Islam does not permit selling an item before purchasing it and taking possession of it.
In (futures trading), a contract is made to purchase a commodity at a specified time in the future, but the commodity is sold before the agreed time. Therefore, the commodity contracted for purchase is resold without the seller ever taking possession of it. Moreover, the structure of a futures contract may involve بيع الدين بالدين, (selling a debt in exchange for another debt), whereby both counter-values are deferred to a future date. This is also a form of transaction prohibited under Islamic law.
3, When selecting a stock, it should represent ownership in an actual company. Moreover, the company should have some illiquid assets, such as buildings, machinery, and other tangible assets. If a company owns only liquid assets, such as cash, investing in its shares is not permissible. This is because the transaction would effectively amount to exchanging money for money. In such a case, the shares cannot be resold at a higher or different price.
As for (indices), we are not purchasing shares in any particular company. Rather, we are trading an index that represents a group of companies. Since an index itself has no underlying assets that are directly owned by the buyer and essentially represents only a price or numerical value, trading it in this manner would also not be permissible.
4, When cash is given as a loan, it is not permissible to demand repayment in excess of the principal amount or to stipulate any benefit in return for granting the loan.
Many brokerage apps allow traders to make purchases worth a much larger amount with only a small amount of capital. For example, if a person has only ₹1,000, a leverage ratio of 1:10 may allow him to take a position worth ₹10,000.
For this facility, the broker may charge a fee. In this case, the amount charged as a fee is effectively a charge for providing the additional ₹9,000 of purchasing power. Therefore, this additional charge is considered interest (riba).Similarly, when a purchased position is held overnight, an additional fee may be charged. This can likewise be regarded as another form of obtaining a benefit in return for providing a loan.
Prop Firms (Funded Accounts)
A company provides certain challenges, and those who successfully complete them are given trading accounts with a specified amount. We can conduct trades through these accounts. The company charges a fee for this accounts. In many cases, the fee is refunded after successfully completing the challenge. However, there is also a condition that a certain portion of the profit earned through the account must be given to the company. Therefore, this arrangement also falls under the category of interest (riba).
5, A trading contract must not contain any condition that invalidates the transaction.
Brokerage apps and prop firms have the right to cancel or close a trade without the trader’s permission if the trader’s losses become excessive. Therefore, the trader does not have complete ownership and control over the product being purchased. This is one of the conditions that invalidates the transaction.